Islam Cannot Escape the Islamic Dilemma đŸ”„

The "Islamic Dilemma" destroys Islam in one clean shot:

OptionResult
Bible is preservedChristianity is true — Islam is false.
Bible is corruptedQur'an is wrong for confirming it — Islam is false.

There’s no third option. Islam dies either way.

Muslims' Excuse:

"The Qur'an only confirms the original Torah and Gospel, not the Bible today!"

Wrong.

👉 Surah 5:43 — "They have the Torah..."
👉 Surah 5:47 — "Let the People of the Gospel judge by what Allah revealed therein."

The Qur'an talks about the Torah and Gospel Christians and Jews HAD in Muhammad’s day — not some "lost" original!

If the Bible was corrupted, why would Allah command Christians to judge by it?

If it was corrupted, why would Allah tell Muhammad to ask the "People of the Book" if he doubted (Surah 10:94)?

Allah himself confirms the Bible.

Muslim dodge:

"But the Bible has contradictions!"

🛑 Stop.

  • If the Bible is corrupted, then your Qur'an is wrong for trusting it.

  • If the Bible is true, then Islam is wrong for denying it.

You can't have it both ways.

Islam is trapped.
Either the Bible is true → Islam is false.
Or the Bible is false → Islam is false.

Islam loses. Always.


Here at Relentless Reasoning, we don’t ask you to take our word for it. We invite you to investigate, question, and reason for yourself. Because truth has nothing to fear from scrutiny.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Exploring the Evolution of Islamic Thought (and Its Critique) How Islam’s Shifting Interpretations Reveal Its Human Origins Islam is often presented as a religion of divine perfection — final, immutable, and unchanging. “Islam is complete,” believers say, quoting Qur’an 5:3 as divine proof. Yet, when we zoom out and examine the actual history of Islamic thought, another picture emerges: one of change , internal conflict , adaptation , and strategic reinterpretation . This isn’t just a religious tradition holding fast against time. It’s a religion wrestling with time  — and often losing. The Myth of Immutability At the heart of Islam’s truth claims lies the idea that God’s final revelation — the Qur’an — is perfect, eternal, and universally applicable . This claim stands or falls on one foundational idea: that Islamic teachings are timeless and unchanging. But the historical and intellectual record tells a different story. The Qur’an was compiled decades after Muhammad’s death , und...
Read more
If Islam Is False, the Evidence Should Speak for Itself — A Straightforward Examination Introduction No belief system, including Islam, should be immune to scrutiny. If a religion makes truth claims—about history, morality, the cosmos, or the divine—those claims are subject to verification and falsification like any other. In this analysis, we examine whether Islam’s foundational claims withstand objective, evidence-based scrutiny. If Islam is false, we do not explain it away. We present the facts plainly. 1. The Claim of Perfect Qur’anic Preservation Islamic Claim: The Qur’an has been perfectly preserved, word for word, since it was revealed to Muhammad in the 7th century. Reality from Historical Evidence: Variant Manuscripts : Early Qur’anic manuscripts, such as the áčąan‘āʟ palimpsest and the Topkapi codex, show variant readings compared to the modern Cairo edition. ([Puin, Gerd-R. 1996], [Sadeghi & Goudarzi, 2012]) Lost Verses : Canonical hadiths (Sahih Muslim, Sah...
Read more
Muhammad's Night Journey to the Non-Existent Temple: A Historical and Theological Contradiction One of the most famous yet puzzling claims in Islamic tradition is that Muhammad was miraculously transported by night from Mecca to Jerusalem’s “Farthest Mosque” (Masjid al-Aqsa), where he allegedly led the prophets in prayer and ascended through the heavens. This claim is based on a single Qur’anic verse (Surah 17:1) and elaborated through various Hadiths and early Islamic sources. However, upon critical examination, this alleged journey—known as al-Isra wal-Mi'raj —unravels into a theological and historical problem that Islamic apologetics struggles to resolve. This article will expose the gaping contradictions within the narrative, the historical impossibility of the journey, and the theological consequences that undermine the credibility of both Muhammad’s prophethood and the Qur'an's divine authorship. 1. Surah 17:1 and the Masjid al-Aqsa Dilemma The cornerstone ve...
Read more